Operation Backlog Completion 2026
Apr 102015
 

Time-of-ContemptOur mad quest to catch up on the entire Witcher saga before The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt comes out in May has brought us to The Time of Contempt, the second full novel in the Witcher Saga. The previous book, Blood of Elves, set the stage for Ciri’s story, which properly began in the short story collection Sword of Destiny.

(Although Sword of Destiny is currently available in English only as a fan translation, an official English version is coming out and can be pre-ordered now.)

When I reviewed Blood of Elves, my only criticism was that it didn’t feel like a complete story, just the setup for a larger plot. I’m happy to say The Time of Contempt does not suffer that problem.

The plot threads the previous book introduced are expanded upon, and it still sets the stage for future events, but its central plot feels more focused. While The Time of Contempt works toward the overarching saga with hints of prophecy and the Wild Hunt (we’ll get back to that in a minute), it concentrates on the political machinations and conflicts that are immediate threats, such as the growing power of the sinister empire Nilfgaard. It also feels much more balanced between its protagonists. While Ciri remains at the core, Geralt has a strong role in the story as well.

As in the previous Witcher books, this one brings together action, believable character interactions, a grim world, and sporadic moments of humor to craft an enjoyable narrative. Whether Geralt’s growing sarcasm at a dinner party full of spies or a truly unsettling scene with a character suffering dehydration, The Time of Contempt drew me into the story and didn’t let me go. It also has a few notable plot twists which I won’t spoil here.

One of my favorite parts was the brief introduction of the Wild Hunt. Previously, all I really knew about the Wild Hunt came from previews of The Witcher 3.

What are these guys? Other than "terrifying"?

What are these guys?
Other than “terrifying”?

Now, in folklore, the “Wild Hunt” is basically a group of spectral huntsmen galloping through the sky. It’s considered a sign of bad luck. The song “Ghost Riders in the Sky” is a reference to the Wild Hunt. The Great Hunt and the Heroes of the Horn in the Wheel of Time series may also be a reference, especially since the hunters in the Wild Hunt are often said to be gods or heroes, such as Woden or King Arthur. Of course, sometimes the Wild Hunt is depicted as evil, too.

I’m sure I could go on all day about folklore and different references to the Wild Hunt, so let’s get back to the Witcher saga’s Wild Hunt. Early on in The Time of Contempt it’s mentioned that the Wild Hunt has been seen, and then we get to see them for ourselves as Ciri flees through a storm filled with specters from her past–and the specters of the Wild Hunt.

The vague, ghastly shapes of riders become visible in the ribbon sliding across the sky. As they come closer and closer, they can be seen ever more clearly. Buffalo horns and ragged crests sway on their helmets, and cadaverous masks show white beneath them. The riders sit on horses’ skeletons, cloaked in ragged caparisons. A fierce gale howls among the willows, blades of lightning slash the black sky. The wind moans louder and louder. No, it’s not the wind. It’s ghostly singing.

The ghastly cavalcade turns and hurtles straight at her. The hooves of the spectral horses stir up the glow of the will ‘o the wisps suspended above the swamps. At the head of the cavalcade gallops the King of the Wild Hunt. A rusty helmet sways above his skull-like face, its gaping eye sockets burning with a livid flame. A ragged cloak flutters. A necklace, empty as an old peapod, rattles against the rusty cuirass, a necklace which, it is said, once contained precious stones, which fell out during the frenzied chase across teh heavens. And became stars…

It isn’t true! It doesn’t exist! It’s a nightmare, a phantom, an illusion! I’m only imagining this!

The King of the Wild Hunt spurs on his skeleton steed and erupts in wild, horrifying laughter.

O, Child of the Elder Blood! You belong to us! You are ours! Join our procession, join our hunt! We will race, race unto the very end, unto eternity, unto the very end of existence! You are ours, starry-eyed daughter of chaos! Join us; learn the joy of the hunt! You are ours. You are one of us! Your place is among us!

‘No!’ she cries. ‘Be gone! You are corpses!’

The King of the Wild Hunt laughs, the rotten teeth snapping above his rusted gorget. The skull’s eye sockets glitter lividly.

Yes, we are corpses. But you are death.”

You know, somehow I don’t think that’s Woden or King Arthur.

What a passage! As soon as I reached that, I couldn’t wait to learn more about the Wild Hunt–and just what’s up with Ciri, our mysterious child of prophecy.

That little tease is the Wild Hunt’s only real presence in The Time of Contempt, but that’s a good thing. If I’d read the book when it first came out, instead of after learning about the third game, I wouldn’t have realized the Wild Hunt’s significance. It serves as a tiny hint of stranger things on the horizon, and I think it works very well.

As for Ciri, we get some definite answers about here in this book, but I won’t spoil them for you. Let’s just say… things are going to get interesting.

The Time of Contempt is an excellent continuation of the Witcher saga, and a stronger novel than its predecessor. If you’re interested in Geralt, Ciri, the Witcher story in general, or just dark fantasy, give it a read.

Mar 022015
 

Cover for The Witcher: Blood of ElvesAfter our look at The Last Wish, I checked out the fan translation of Sword of Destiny to make sure I had the necessary knowledge for the story (since it sets up an important plot point), and moved on to the next book in the Witcher series.

Unlike the previous two, Blood of Elves is a full fantasy novel, without the strange fairy tale overtones. It continues Ciri’s storyline, which seems to extend into The Witcher 3.

(If you’ve read The Last Wish but you don’t intend to read Sword of Destiny, Ciri is Pavetta’s daughter, and therefore bound to Geralt by destiny.)

Make no mistake, despite the cover of my copy prominently displaying Geralt and the back description emphasizing his responsibility, this book is very much about Ciri.

Geralt does have some important scenes, as he struggles against sinister forces that are searching for the girl–some for political reasons, some for reasons left unknown. These forces get some key moments of their own, and a sizable section is devoted to other world powers dealing with war, politics, and the potential that Ciri might be alive. Those chapters in particular are very dialogue-heavy, which is one of my few complaints about the novel. I enjoy dialogue, but some stretches contained so little description or action that even I felt a bit put out.

On the other hand, a few dialogue-only scenes used the format to their advantage to surprise the reader in a way they couldn’t if they included the action. For example, in one such exchange, Lambert guides Ciri through combat exercises, sprinkled with taunts and mockery from him, only to reveal at the very end that she’s been blindfolded the entire time. While it would have been pretty cool to see her performing these moves blindfolded, the unexpected revelation at the end makes its impact greater.

The majority of the book focuses on Ciri’s combat training at Kaer Morhern, her journey with Triss and Geralt, and her magic training with Yennefer. In this way, we not only get to see Ciri as she grows from the child in Sword of Destiny to a young woman skilled in both combat and magic, we also get to see new dimensions of other characters–particularly Yennefer, who is much more sympathetic here, with hints of her softer side.

My only complaint about the plot itself is that it is not very self-contained. While the short story collections could stand on their own, this novel needs its sequel. It introduces conflicts and questions, but resolves very few of them. It focuses on Ciri’s development and sets up a plot, as you might expect if this was just the first part of a larger novel.

That said, it’s an enjoyable setup, and I’ll be interested to see where the next book takes the plot. Bottom line, if you enjoyed the previous entries in the Witcher novel series and/or are interested in learning more about Ciri, check out Blood of Elves.

Feb 062015
 

Reliquary by Douglas Preston and Lincoln ChildOf all the books I’ve read for my Readings in the Genre (RIG) classes, one of my favorites was Relic, by Douglas Preston and Lincoln Child. I loved its sinister atmosphere, enjoyable characters, and fun inclusion of science. I couldn’t wait to read the sequel, Reliquary.

Much to my disappointment, Reliquary didn’t live up to the original. It wasn’t a bad book, but it just wasn’t very good.

For starters, the first half of the book painstakingly leads toward a “twist” that was revealed at the very end of Relic. If you started with the sequel or don’t remember that final cliffhanger, it works fine, and it’s still a well-written moment, but something many of the readers would be familiar with–which may have even led them to buy the book–shouldn’t have been treated as such a huge revelation.

Most of the science ties to that revelation, as well, which was another disappointment for me. I enjoyed the way Relic used science to unravel the mystery… not so much when it’s a mystery the audience already knows the answer to.

Next, the book devotes a considerable chunk of pages to a subplot that could be removed entirely without much damage to the plot. At most, it would lose some societal commentary it better illustrated through characters like Mephisto and Sergeant Hayward, anyway.

XenomorphThird, while the overall plot is interesting, it just doesn’t carry the same tension and mystery as the first one. The creatures in Reliquary are dangerous and cause gruesome deaths, but somehow aren’t as menacing as Mbwun. Maybe it’s similar to Alien, where the terror created by one solitary monster diminishes in effect when spread to a mob. Even at this book’s most dangerous moments, it didn’t live up to the heart-pounding moments of Relic.

Finally, for the second book in what eventually became known as the Special Agent Pendergast series, Pendergast is barely in it at all. He has a couple of cool moments, but most of the attention is on Margo, Smithback, and D’Agosta. They drive most of the plot, and Pendergast feels almost like an afterthought–added in because of positive reception to the character and not because the story needed him.

I did enjoy some moments–and the final twist took me completely by surprise. Just moments after I thought, “No, it can’t be going there,” it went there. (A little more foreshadowing might have helped, however.) Although I’ve criticized the book a lot here, I wanted to know what happened next and it wasn’t hard to keep reading.

Should you read Reliquary? If you really want to go in order, it’s a decent read with some good moments. But most fans agree this is the weakest of the Pendergast novels, and I don’t think you’d miss anything by jumping from Relic straight to The Cabinet of Curiosities.